I’m one of those geeks who wore a “Frodo Lives” pin through the 60’s.Frodo Baggins was my hero, then and now, and not even the glorious spectacle created by Peter Jackson can make me forget that.Tags: Can You For MeBest Retail Manager Cover LetterWriting A Case Study Apa StyleHalo Vs Call Of Duty EssayEssay On Capital Punishment Should Be PublishedSave Money Or Spend Money EssayEssay On Introduction To MyselfTurabian Research Paper Cover PageBetween Essay Mind Physical Relationship World
It’s hard to further downsize a hobbit, but the movies have done it.
As crazy as I am (friends will abundantly testify) about the Jackson movies, I was dismayed by so much screenwriting aimed at knocking down the main character.
Frodo is still recovering from the Weathertop stab wound. In the book, it is a powerful Elf warrior, Glorfindel, who finds the wounded Ringbearer and his friends in the wildness. Suddenly the foremost Rider spurred his horse forward. With great effort Frodo sat upright and brandished his sword. ” His voice sounded thin and shrill in his own ears. Frodo’s diminishment in is capped during the Osgiliath scene, another major departure from the book. I guessed how it would be from the moment of that preachy “what are we fighting for” speech delivered by Sam in the ruins of Osgiliath.
The later decision is even more heroic, because Frodo has faced the enemy, and knows now that he may die during the quest. Glorfindel sets Frodo on his horse for the flight from the Wraiths to the Ford of Rivendell. He felt the quick surge and heave as the horse left the river and struggled up the stony path . His enemies laughed at him with a harsh and chilling laughter. This scene, written to give Faramir’s character a conflict to overcome, does little but shrink Frodo yet again. As full of marvels as the Peter Jackson movie is, I was truly disappointed by his interpretation of Frodo.
Even if you argue that this is simply another instance of Frodo stripped of his will by the Ring, why wouldn’t the Wraiths be hot on the Ringbearer’s trail after such a display?
And why, if this has happened, would Sauron believe Pippin has the Ring, after the impulsive hobbit’s misadventure with the palantir? It took two no, three - hobbits to complete the quest!Still, let’s not forget that if Samwise had been in charge, there would have been no Gollum left alive to bear the Ring into the fire.Frodo is Tolkien’s hero, and Elijah Wood should have played the movie’s hero, too, but it didn’t get written that way. Here we see a clear instance of Frodo’s diminished role as well as violations of the laws of Tolkien’s world.Changes in the character of Frodo, and violations of the rules of Tolkien canon go hand in hand.Frodo, by himself, in agony, manages this with the help of Glorfindel’s splendid steed, Asfaloth. Under the influence of the Wraiths (now mounted on dragons instead of horses) he goes up onto the city wall to offer his enemies the Ring. That tears the beating heart out of the book--the friendship and loyalty that binds those two characters is the core of Tolkien’s story. Jackson’s creation is little more than a sacrificial lamb, the sweet guy who pulls the short straw, a soldier who comes home from the war broken beyond repair. Instead of being merely Arwen’s semi-conscious baggage, as he is in the movie, Frodo is the one who, alone, turns at the Ford to defy the Wraiths. When Sam seizes him before the Wraith does, they roll to the bottom of a stairway, and Frodo comes up sword in hand ready to kill Sam, who has just saved his life, and the quest. Poor, beautiful Frodo Jackson made him contradictory, fading, expendable, perhaps so we don’t have to cry too hard at the end, when Frodo sails away with the elves, facing a lonely demise in the Valinor V. And before someone jumps on me about Sam, yes, it wouldn’t have got done without him.He is the common man evolving into an uncommon hero.Is a sort of 21st Century inverse snobbery at work here? I don’t know, and I don’t pretend to know, but Peter Jackson’s Frodo isn’t Tolkien’s.It’s like revisionist historyrevisionist Tolkien--and I don’t buy it.